قالب وردپرس درنا توس
Home / Tips and Tricks / Best music streaming app: Compared Spotify, Apple Music, Tidal, Amazon and Google Play

Best music streaming app: Compared Spotify, Apple Music, Tidal, Amazon and Google Play

  01 spotify headphones

Sarah Tew / CNET

Of course, vinyl makes a big revival among audiophiles, but streaming still has the future of listening to music locked. Streaming music is cheap or even free (in the case of Pandora and Spotify) and surpasses any physical format when it comes to convenience. Do not worry if you are concerned about the sound quality; in some cases these subscription services sound better than, or at least indistinguishable from, a CD.

We have viewed the leading on-demand music streaming options ̵

1; Spotify, Apple Music, Pandora and Tidal – as well as Google Play Music and Amazon Music Unlimited to see how they all add up to your subscription. While most leading services have music catalogs of more than 40 million tracks, each has their own unique advantages and disadvantages for a potential subscriber to consider. We have deliberately omitted services that only play music in a radio format. They all offer a kind of family plan that allows you to share your service for a fee with others, and listen offline via mobile devices, although not all are available on your desktop.

Note: CNET may derive a portion of the revenue from the sale of services on this page.

Our top choice: Spotify is the best for most people

Let's get started. Although it is a tight race between Spotify and Apple Music Spotify wins our subscription vote with a fun, easy-to-use interface, an extensive catalog and the best device compatibility. Spotify & # 39; s free layer had some recent improvements making it the best free option.

Apple Music is a close second partly because it is the only one of the "big four" with a digital safe to store your own library of songs. And if you own an Apple HomePod ($ 299 at Walmart) you need this subscription service if you want to recall music with your voice. It is also the ideal companion for a new iPod Touch, which is surprisingly a thing .

Tidal is in third place, which is also worth a look if you are interested in the best audio quality.

Google Play Music and Amazon Music Unlimited are in the game . Although they were not at the top of our list, they are all worthy options for users with specific needs or requirements. For example, if you think the YouTube-free ad-free service is important, Google Play Music will be used for free. And Amazon offers a reduced Echo-only version of its service, which can set the tone if you already have an Alexa-heavy household.

While Pandora & # 39; s free service is excellent, the on-demand service still lags behind the others in catalog width when it comes to songs and albums.

It is also worth mentioning Qobuz, a streaming platform launched this year in the US . It is still too early to call, but in the first instance this Tidal competitor blushes a clean interface, hi-res audio streams and the possibility to buy music without loss. However, the catalog is not entirely at the Tidal or Spotify level.

And don't forget: these plans all offer free trial periods and the standard registrations are "no contract" options. So you are largely free to come and go as you please. Do not be afraid to try the water of a rival service if you are not completely satisfied.

So here is what we think of the six best music streaming services, presented in alphabetical order. It is worth noting that all these services work on the most important platforms: Android, iOS, PC and Mac.


Spotify is the pioneer in the field of music streaming and is perhaps the best known. It offers a number of different composite music discovery services, including the Discover Weekly playlist and is constantly experimenting with new ones, such as the only stations in Australia . The (now optional) Facebook integration of the service makes sharing music on Spotify easier than that of competitors, and offers the possibility to send a song or album, collaborate on playlists with friends or look at where your Facebook friends listen to.

The Good

  • Free version is impressively robust.
  • It is easy to create your own playlists and synchronize them for offline listening.
  • User-friendly apps that are regularly updated and that have sufficient functions without being overwhelming.
  • Allows you to follow artists and be notified when they release new music or announce an upcoming show.
  • Very personalized custom playlists.
  • Spotify Connect simplifies the connection with wireless speakers and AV receivers.

The Bad

  • Ads in the free service can be intrusive.

Best for: People who want a solid all-round service, and especially for people who like to create, browse and share playlists for each scenario.

Apple Music

  album-view-apple-music "height =" 0 "width =" 270 "data-original =" https://cnet2.cbsistatic.com/img/l-CB65SiQ7pGe1z2aS3BajCjjlE=/270x0/ 2018/04/12 / af2642ac-1674-40e5-858f-90f3de18a272 / apple-music.png


Although initially suffered from teething problems Apple Music has become one of the most popular streaming services . It offers numerous functions and a wealth of discount options for families and students. There is also a ton of composite playlists, many hand-made by musicians and tastemakers, but the robust options for parts built into Spotify are still lacking .

The Good

  • It combines your iTunes library with music that you do not own, which completes what you can play.
  • A combination of human music experts and algorithms helps you find music that you want to hear based on what you play.
  • You can control what you hear or search for new music with Siri on iOS devices.
  • Has music locker through iTunes Match ($ 25, £ 22 or AU $ 35 a year).
  • Currently the only choice for Apple HomePod users who want to use voice control.

The Bad

  • As you would expect, the Android app and experience is not as smooth as the iOS.
  • Does not work with old iPods (except iPod Touch) .

Best for: Those who want to listen to albums and songs they have added to iTunes or use an Apple HomePod.


Owned by hip-hop mogul Jay Z, Tidal is the only "large" streaming music service that offers lossless audio streaming with sound quality almost identical to – or better than – CD. Tidal has in the past offered exclusive content from his superstar co-owners – Beyonce's "Lemonade" or Kanye West's "The Life of Pablo" – but this trend has happily declined . However, sometimes albums are inexplicably missing and these include any album from Metallica ( Spotify exclusive ) or Boards of Canada & # 39; s groundbreaking music has the right to children. If you are an audiophile, an R&B or hip hop fan, or a mix of both, then Tidal might be for you.

The Good

  • Hifi music streams.
  • Lots of video content, including concert live streams.
  • Offers occasional ticket presale.
  • Great focus on under the radar (mostly hip hop) artists.
  • Profiles and record reviews on every page.

The Bad

  • The mobile apps and web player are not as simple as some others.
  • The catalog is not & # 39; t as exhausting as that of Spotify.

The best for: Musically minded purists who care a lot about sound quality and discover new, emerging artists.

Google Play Music

Although the will soon be replaced by YouTube Music Google Play Music works as a streaming music service and a music cabinet. This allows you to store and stream your entire music library (up to 50,000 songs), as well as any of the 30 million songs in the catalog. Instead of playlists, well-composed radio stations are the striking feature of Play Music. Unlike playlists, which are finite and contain specific songs, radio stations play endlessly and are often updated.

The Good

  • This hybrid service seamlessly integrates your personal collection with the streaming catalog.
  • Monthly rate includes subscription to YouTube Music: commercial free streaming on YouTube and YouTube Music.
  • Offers music locker service for free.

The Bad

  • The lack of a timeline for its replacement is frustrating.
  • The interface is less fun than competitors, especially on desktop.

Best for: Google fans who want to combine the music they have purchased with streaming selections.

Amazon Music Unlimited

Amazon is a newcomer in the streaming music scene.

Screenshot by Xiomara Blanco / CNET

Amazon Music Unlimited is the & # 39; mature & # 39; version of Amazon Prime Music which Prime subscribers receive for free. It offers a greatly expanded catalog for an additional monthly release. Instead of focusing on the newest music as some others do here, the service offers recommended playlists and radio stations that are grouped around artists you've already listened to.

The Good

The Bad

  • Artist profiles do not have biographies.
  • Officially advertised as "tens of millions" of numbers strong, it is unclear whether the catalog is just as large as its competitors listed here (see table below).
  • The service no longer includes a music box .

Best for: Amazon Prime members who want to save a few dollars on a decent music catalog.

  pandora "height =" 0 "width =" 270 "data-original =" https://cnet2.cbsistatic.com/img/vSrpelEglxaIazwTNkFF3Z8sAUw=/270x0/2018/04/09/d1420d73-3545-44c1-aa32 -bbc79377d33f / pandora.png

Screenshot: Ty Pendlebury / CNET

Pandora Premium

Now a full-fledged streaming service with the addition of a la carte Premium and no-ads Plus levels, Pandora also offers one of the most popular radio services in the US. As a result, the company offers more flexibility than most competitors and gains subscribers, even if it lags behind in terms of total catalog size.

The Good

  • Thanks to the free version, the service has one of the largest user files.
  • Pandora & # 39; s "Music Genome Project" analyzes each song on 450 different characteristics to give better suggestions.

The Bad

  • The size of the catalog is no larger than that of the competition (last estimated at 2 million).
  • The audio quality is one of the lowest available, even on the Premium subscription (192 Kbps).
  • It does not really provide an incentive for an upgrade compared to the others here.
  • Not available outside of the US.

Best for: Pandora Premium is especially interesting for existing Pandora users who want to be able to choose exactly what they listen to, but almost no one else.

Compared to Music Streaming Services

Amazon Music Unlimited Apple Music Google Play Music Pandora Spotify tide
Monthly allowance Prime members: $ 7.99, £ 7.99, na; Non-Prime members: $ 9.99, £ 9.99, AU $ 11.99; Alexa service only: free $ 9.99, £ 9.99, AU $ 11.99 $ 9.99, £ 9.99, AU $ 11.99 Plus: $ 4.99; Premium: $ 9.99 $ 9.99, £ 9.99, AU $ 11.99, $ 12.99 with Hulu
Premium: $ 9.99, £ 9.99, AU $ 14.99; HiFi: $ 19.99, £ 19.99, AU $ 23.99
Free option? Yes, with advertisements
No. 19659094
Yes Yes, with advertisements Yes, with advertisements
No. 19659094
Free trial period 30 days 3 months 30 days 60 days 30 days 3 months
Music library size 50 million 50 million More than 40 million
50 million 50 million
Maximum bit rate
256 Kbps
320 Kbps
192 Kbps
320 Kbps
Sharing family? Yes, $ 14.99, £ 14.99, AU $ 17.99 for up to 6 users Yes, $ 14.99, £ 14.99, AU $ 17.99 for up to 6 users Yes, $ 14.99, £ 14.99, AU $ 17.99 per month for up to 6 users Yes, $ 14.99 for up to 6 users Yes, $ 5, £ 5, AU $ 6 per month per additional user, up to 5 Yes, 50% discount on each additional account, up to 4
Student discount
No. 19659100
Yes, price varies by country
No. 19659094
$ 4.99 (Premium) $ 4.99 (US only) Premium: $ 4.99, HiFi: $ 9.99 (US only)
American military discount
No. 19659100
No. 19659094
No. 19659094
No. 19659094
Listen offline Mobile and desktop Mobile only Mobile only Mobile only Mobile and desktop Mobile only
Radio stations Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
No. 19659094
No. 19659100
No. 19659094
Yes Yes Yes Yes
Music video & # 39; s
No. 19659100
No. 19659094
No. 19659094
Yes Yes
Music locker functionality
No. 19659100
Yes Yes
No. 19659094
No. 19659094
No. 19659094

What else do you need to know?

Streaming music services offer a la carte listening, as opposed to streaming radio. Sarah Tew / CNET

Streaming radio versus on-demand

This guide covers on-demand music streaming services and for that reason we have deliberately omitted services that only play music in a radio format. Pandora excluded this list until last year, but now that the company also offers a Premium layer it has been included here. Slacker Radio TuneIn and iHeartRadio are now services that play music stations based on a theme or artist, without explicitly choosing tracks.

Music cases: your MP3's in the cloud

Amazon was one of the first services to offer uploading your MP3 collection in the cloud, but this was officially stopped in 2018 . In the meantime, with the Apple and Google services listed above, you can still combine your personal music collection with the streaming catalog, so if you have invested money in digital music over the years, that money will not be wasted. These so-called "music boxes" are available independently of the subscription services below, but also work with them for subscribers of both.

Size of music catalog compared

The number of songs offered by a music service was one of the most important distinguishing factors, but most now offer 30 million songs or more. However, depending on your favorite genre, some of them have a more robust catalog with many artists under the radar, indie or hip hop. If you are musically minded and constantly looking for your favorite new band, a streaming service such as Spotify or Tidal might be for you. Users who are less ambitious in expanding their musical taste will be satisfied with the smaller catalogs Amazon Music Unlimited and Google Play Music. Apple Music is somewhere in the middle and offers a healthy mix of regular songs and underground strangers.

The best sounding bookshelf speakers of the Audiophiliac : Top choices of the CNET audio expert.

Originally published a few years ago, this list is regularly updated.

Source link